Research On The Effectiveness of Performance Management and Performance Review
Top : Research
Everyone has opinions about performance management and the effectiveness of performance reviews, mostly in the negative.
Fortunately there's a fair amount of research on effectiveness, and also what aspects of managing performance and reviews work best.
Unfortunately, a lot of that research is published in journals and other venues to which most of us cannot gain easy access.
In this section we'll provide links to various research studies that have been published in management journals, journals of psychology and related publications.
Our rule for most of this site is to review and include ONLY material that can be accessed free of charge, and without registration. For this topic, because there isn't much free access, we are including links to abstracts that ARE free to read, but the full articles often require a paid subscription.
If you have access to a university library, you may find they have the journals in question, so if you want to read a full journal article make sure to record the citation.
By Robert D. Bretz Jr., Cornell University - This review of the literature spreads light on the state of performance appraisal, and includes references and citations. While undertaken in 1992, still a valuable resource. Viewed 924 Times )
By Jenkins , Alan - This paper reviews existing literatures on the analysis of performance appraisal (PA) paying special attention to those which try to take into account the %u201Csocial context%u201D of appraisal systems and processes. The special place of political action within these processes is underlined and the different levels at which politics need to be considered in research are outlined. Research on politics is considered and shown to lack an adequate consideration of the social relations involved in the reciprocal interactions between PA tools and processes and users interpretation and manipulation of them. Viewed 1294 Times )
By NA - Contemporary performance appraisal (PA) has become an important tool in the overseeing of employees in work. Little of the vast literature however, has focused on its effects on the individual, beyond simple descriptions that inform its management implementation. This article firstly examines the changing nature of employee management under PA, before it investigates the contemporary usage of PA and the effects on women. This is illustrated with research, gathered from a case study in the Midlands. Viewed 1625 Times )
By Government of Canada - Performance management is recognized as being essential to creating a high-performing workplace, and "organizations where people are properly managed bring about self-motivation to do a good job." See footnote 2 In his Nineteenth Annual Report to the Prime Minister on the Public Service of Canada, the Clerk of the Privy Council set clear expectations for performance management in the public service and stressed its importance in achieving excellence, stating that managers are to set high standards for individual performance and are to expect employees to meet those standards. See footnote 3 This report analyzes the results of the PSES as they pertain to performance management and sheds light on the relationships between performance management and other aspects of employees' work and work environment. Although these relationships cannot be interpreted as ones of cause and effect, information on them can help managers and human resources leaders better target their efforts to strengthen performance management in the public service. The survey contained three questions related to performance management that were used for the purpose of this analysis. Viewed 139 Times )
By DONNA L.M. MITCHELL AND ESTHER GREEN - ABSTRACT: To accomplish effective performance reviews and appraisals that respect employee dignity, managers must cultivate a wide range of competencies. Systems are required to observe and collect data, cue and measure observations, and then interpret behavior. Managers regard handling disciplinary problems and criticizing subordinates' performances as the most stressful aspects of their work. Evaluating an employee's performance at an annual meeting is one of the tasks managers most dread. Viewed 1347 Times )
By DDI - Some research findings (survey based) on the process of managing employee performance by DDI Viewed 838 Times )
By Evelina W. Cross, PhD, RD; Amelia Estepa Asperin, PhD; Mary Frances Nettles - The purpose of the research was to develop a competency-based performance appraisal resource for evaluating school nutrition (SN) managers and assistants/technicians. Viewed 1488 Times )
By PeopleIQ - 96 percent of employees, mangers and CEOs agree that performance appraisals should differentiate high and low performers. But only 18 percent agree that their current system actually does differentiate high and low performers. That's one of the results of a survey done about performance management and appraisal. See the rest. Viewed 800 Times )
By Peter Smith - In its latest attempt to improve performance, the British National Health Service (NHS) has turned to the business models of performance management. A range of managerial instruments has been deployed, signaling national priorities to local managers and seeking to offer the information, incentives, and capacity they need to respond appropriately. The arrangements are intellectually coherent and offer the prospect of major improvements in the quality of British health care. However, implementation is at an early stage, and some key issues have to be addressed. The various performance management instruments have not yet been properly aligned, and greater conceptual clarity in implementation is required. Performance management will not be fully effective unless adequate capacity--in information, leadership, and managerial resources--is made available. Viewed 1154 Times )
Library Home Page |
Pages Updated On: 10-Sep-2014 - 12:35:29