What Is Rater Bias?

It's well known, from the social sciences, that when people evaluate something or someone, their evaluations reflect the thing or person being assessed, AND, the evaluator's built in biases. As human beings our judgements about many things are affected by our own perceptual googles. The effects of evaluator perceptions introduces highly subjective factors that make many evaluations more or less inaccurate.

How does this relate to performance appraisal? Bias becomes a bigger and bigger factor to the extent that the criteria for evaluation become more vague, general, and abstract. For example, if a criterion says "Sells one million dollars in homes", bias is less likely to invalidate the evaluation using that criterion, since the criterion is objective and measurable. However, if the criterion is "Sells a whoe bunch of houses", then the evaluation using this criterion is likely to be influenced by various biases, because it's much vaguer.

Rater bias is a major problem when managers rate employees using scales that are vague, or highly subjective, so if you use rating scales, it's likely that biases come into play.

Biases can work to inflate employee ratings, or to deflate them. And, the effects are largely unpredictable, since different managers will apply different biases. Sometimes the same manager will exhibit different rater biases across different employees.

Managers will do well to be aware of their possible evaluation biases, so they can try to eliminate them. And, of course, the more objective, measurable, and precise the criteria used, the less likely bias will contaminate employee ratings. However, it's true that biases are simply a built in hazard of using rating systems, and cannot be totally eliminated.

For an outline of specific biases, go back to the ranking and ratings main page.

• Busy? We walk you through the complete process of managing performance, from goal setting to addressing performance problems and discipline issues. Contains ALL our help cards, and here's a sneak peak: Walk the path WITH employees.
• Well, we do. Here's a low cost mini-guide FOR EMPLOYEES so they can be active participants in a truly collaborative performance review.
• Well, you can't, so this short LearnByte guides explains how to identify barriers to employee performance, in order to clear them away. Diagnosing is the key to productivity improvement.
• Ok. Now you can have a reusable checklist so you don't miss any of the critical steps needed to succeed with your employee reviews.
• Save huge amounts of time and frustration during performance review meetings, by having set proper goals and objectives for the employee. Isn't that your job? To make sure employees know what they need to accomplish?
• If you think performance management = performance appraisal, you NEED this badly.
• ...and how damaging to your employees. We'll walk you through the entire process of dealing with performance problems with one goal: To FIX them, and improve productivity. And we ask for less than 20 minutes of your time.
• Prefer Kindle? Many of our quick read helpcards and also our books on performance management and reviews and how to make them work, are available via Amazon on the KINDLE. Click here to go direct.
• It's 2013, not 1945 and it's time to lose the industrial mindset and use management tools for THIS century. Here's ten steps to improvement.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

jQuery Image Slider With Thumbnails by WOWSlider.com v2.6